The literary fest:
Authors and readers alike wait eagerly for such festivals. Debate, dialogue,
readings and stories, the fest had everything that one seeks from an assembly
of writers and readers. If acclaimed writers left their impression, Oprah
Winfrey stole the show.
The controversy:
What was the controversy about? Was it regarding the banned book or the person
who wrote it? Was it regarding the sentiments of a particular religion? Was it
regarding freedom of speech or expression? Was there an election factor? Whatever the reason, no one was interested in the
solution. The so called ‘hardliners’ and the so called 'liberals' did not help
the cause. Perceived and real threats made matters worse. The on and off
approach of the government was on expected lines.
Ban is on the book,
not the man: Is the author in question so influential to affect the wisdom
of Indian people? The book is already banned. The author was scheduled to speak on a
different topic. He has visited India before. So why were people
protesting against the author's visit? Can't he speak on any other book written by him, not even through video
conferencing?
No freedom is
absolute and there is no justification to cause offense: Some authors read excerpts
from a banned book. What were they trying to prove? Is any freedom absolute?
Every person has freedom to express his feeling and views. At the same time, no
freedom is absolute. One has to respect the sentiments and beliefs of their
fellow beings. The existence of many religions is a reality of this world,
which one has to accept. Everyone is free to practice his or her religion or
not to follow any religion. Yes, one can question certain practices, but in a
persuasive manner, without causing offense. Again, the same applies to the protestors. The problem is no one is interested
in adopting a balanced approach.
Feast - In the end, the author in question got
more attention than perhaps he could have got, if he was allowed to visit. Many
others may have gone unnoticed. The gains were in the form of TRPs for some,
increased publicity for some, and opportunity to score points on rival parties
for some others. It provided opportunity for other countries to question
India's image.
People will continue
to differ and the debate will continue for times to come. The perspective and
approach is equally important as is the outcome of such debates in the
society.